Wales vs New Zealand Review – Nations Championship 2026
Wales 35 – 28 New Zealand
Absolutely unbelievable.
Wales haven’t beaten the All Blacks since 1953. This is a fixture independent of the quality of the sides; Wales are playing their stronger foil, and even more powerful rugby culture whose power has barely waned even in its darkest days, let alone the apocalyptic state of Wales off pitch.
For how much criticism the coaching team have come under for the lack of progress Wales have made and their lack of clear identity, this showed exactly what this team can do. Several powerful carrying efforts gave them the go-forward to score tries, and they came out flying in both halves with all their energy. But the decider was on the other side of the ball; with only 35% possession, Wales simply refused to concede, turning the grit they’ve exhibited all year into an oppressive defensive effort that denied the All Blacks again and again.
There are work-ons; the lineout barely improved and could prove costly in close games like this, so that’ll be Tandy’s first focus, and for how good Wales were with ball-in-hand, they simply need far more possession than 35% if they are to take advantage of it. Cutting out those errors will give them the potential to push back into the top 8, and beat these top sides more consistently.
But for today, all that matters is the win. The guys gave their all for the jersey, and they can look ahead to Australia knowing they have earned it.
Player Ratings:
1: Nicky Smith 8
The scrum went fairly well, beyond a few instances where the All Blacks took control. Smith put in a good shift around the park, slowing the All Blacks’ ball down well, though his efforts were fairly overshadowed.
2: Dewi Lake 8
There were two Dewi Lakes in this game; the player around the pitch who put in 24 tackles and constantly drove Wales forward, claiming a much-deserved try; and the setpiece Dewi Lake, who was the main architect of a fairly weak lineout. Still, his leadership really shone through in Wales’ endgame efforts.
3: Archie Griffin 8
Built on a pretty good showing last time. Looked solid in the scrum, and claimed his second try in a row as he looks to be growing more comfortable in international rugby.
4: Dafydd Jenkins 9
38 tackles; a completely unfathomable workrate on both sides of the ball and firmly one of the cornerstones of this Welsh victory. Looked completely gassed by the end, and you can see why.
5: Adam Beard 7
Also held back by Wales’ weak lineout, which he was much involved in. Still, his physicality was clear as he put in a great work effort around the park, hitting rucks and holding back the All Blacks’ ball carriers.
6: James Botham 10
If James Botham wasn’t playing, Wales may not have won. That is the scope of his efforts in restraining the All Blacks’ attack and giving Wales go-forward. 10 carries (a high number given Wales’ possession) and 30 tackles, alongside massive try-saving efforts sealed the deal and cemented Botham’s place in the 6 jersey.
7: Jac Morgan 9
Similarly influential on both sides of the ball, with an exceptional 4 turnovers. Strong leadership in Lake’s absence, too, as Wales kept level heads and kept the error rate low towards the lategame.
8: Taine Basham 8
Looked very strong in Aaron Wainwright’s absence, as he consistently kept Wales moving forwards. Massive workrate in a fairly short time, given how early he was replaced for Plumtree, but made every minute of it as he topped Wales’ carrying charts.
9: Tomos Williams 9
Williams looked back to his best as he guided the attack with some crisp, Gloucester-like offloads. Still kicked away a lot of possession, which didn’t help Wales’ numbers by the end, but what he gave the team with ball-in-hand was enough for a win.
10: Sam Costelow 8
Brilliant passing game reminiscent of his club form, and nailed all of his conversions. Similar to last week, also was held back by his decision making and made some only ok line kicks, but a much improved effort overall. Should hold onto the jersey for Australia too.
11: Gabriel Hamer-Webb 7
Was ok – he handled Fehi Fineanganofo well, and came off his wing a lot to get involved, but looked held back by an early injury, as he didn’t get much done with the ball.
12: Max Llewellyn 8
Similar to last week; great defensive effort, will be gutted to spill the ball close to the line like that. Brought a great defensive presence and helped Wales compete at the power game.
13: Eddie James 10
Even better than last week; like Botham, his efforts stood out in giving Wales the win. Exceptional on defence; 25/2 is an insane sheet for a centre; and gave Wales another powerful weapon on attack. Claimed a well-deserved try out wide, and stopped another try himself.
14: Louis Rees-Zammit 9
The All Blacks were a lot more prepared than Japan, but Rees-Zammit still set fire to their defence with 4 line breaks and more meters than anyone else. Strong defensive effort too, preventing the All Blacks from going out wide.
15: Blair Murray 8
Whereas his footwork and pace were the keys last week, his kicking game won it for Wales this week with powerful clearing kicks to give Wales territory. Still electric with ball-in-hand, but was also very effective in defence, as he made some crucial interventions out wide.
BENCH 9
I’ve started rating the bench as one entity instead of looking at individuals, as it better reflects the way international rugby is played and Tandy rarely gives many players gametime.
Wales needed impact to close out the game and they got it; Elias tidied up the lineout and the front five replacements were massive on the defensive front, especially the renewed form of Gareth Thomas. Taine Plumtree also proved his doubters wrong with some great interventions over the ball, and Dan Edwards got to stop another try. Just as important as the starters in giving Wales the win.
My Team for Australia:
- Nicky Smith
- Dewi Lake
- Archie Griffin
- Dafydd Jenkins
- Ben Carter
- James Botham
- Jac Morgan
- Taine Basham
- Tomos Williams
- Sam Costelow
- Ellis Mee
- Max Llewellyn
- Eddie James
- Louis Rees-Zammit
- Blair Murray
BENCH
- Ryan Elias
- Rhys Carré/Barratt
- Dillon Lewis
- Teddy Williams
- Kane James
- Che Hope
- Dan Edwards
- Macs Page
Some more rotation could be justified, given the amount of effort that must’ve gone into that win and with a match against a very physical Australia incoming. I’ve kept a lot of the same team for obvious reasons, though I’d also like to see some new players given a chance with the pressure somewhat taken off Wales.
Rhys Barratt, Che Hope, and Macs Page could come in for their first caps off the bench, given a lot of the squad are more settled. Barratt’s dynamism and workrate makes him a good substitute once Archie Griffin leaves, with Dillon Lewis’ size adding more bulk to the scrum alongside him. Hope will earn a cap at some point, and while Reuben Morgan-Williams was strong for his 15 minutes against the All Blacks, Wales need more options ahead of the World Cup. Page also brings a lot of energy off the bench, and with Australia’s current defensive issues, his X-factor could prove a problem for their defence lategame.
Elsewhere, the lack of lineout improvements with Beard suggests Carter is the better option. The backrow retains largely the same shape, assuming that Aaron Wainwright remains injured. I’ve brought Kane James as a replacement, as he should be able to help bring a similar dynamism to Basham off the bench, while adding an additional element of breakdown skill that should slow down the Wallabies’ elite ball carriers.
As for the backline, I think Wales have found their first-choice players after that game, though Edwards will continue to challenge Costelow and could start should Wales benefit more from attacking at the line. Tom Rogers also offers another aerial element over Blair Murray, though it looks like Joseph-Aukuso Sua’ali’i will be staying at outside centre, so they should be able to contain his aerial skill. To help with that, though, I’ve brought back Ellis Mee to try and threaten Australia’s high ball should the match become a kicking contest.